Private carer or care agency: which should you choose?
The real difference isn't the carer, it's who's the employer. A home care agency employs and manages its carers, carries the insurance and sorts out cover, and charges more for doing all of that. Employing a private carer yourself usually costs less an hour, but it makes you the employer, with the tax, pension and cover duties that come with the job.
The two routes, and who carries the load
When families talk about a "private carer", they usually mean one of two quite different arrangements, and it's worth being clear which one you're weighing up before you compare prices.
The first is a fully managed home care agency. You pay the agency, and it employs the carers, pays their wages, runs the background checks, holds the insurance, writes the care plan and supervises the work. If your regular carer is off sick, the agency sends someone else. You have less say over exactly who turns up, and you pay more, because that whole back-office is built into the hourly rate.
The second is employing a carer directly. You find the person, agree their pay, and they work for you. The hourly figure is usually lower, because there's no agency overhead or margin on top. In return, the responsibilities an agency would normally shoulder, from tax to insurance to covering holidays, land on you.
There's a middle option too: an introductory agency that matches you with a self-employed carer. It finds the person and steps back, so you still deal directly with the carer and most of the duties remain yours. That can work well, but it's closer to employing someone yourself than to using a managed agency, and the next sections explain why that matters.
What each route costs
Here's the money side set out plainly. The headline hourly figures look very different, but they're not comparing like with like, because one of them already includes costs the other leaves you to pay separately.
| Route | How you pay | Typical figure (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Managed agency, visiting care | Per hour, to the agency | Around £20–£25 an hour, arranged privately |
| The full cost of one safe hour (a useful yardstick) | Per hour, minimum | £34.42 (Homecare Association, 2026/27, England) |
| A carer you employ: their hourly pay | Per hour, to the carer | At least the National Living Wage, £12.71 from April 2026 |
| Employer on-costs, if you employ | On top of the wage | Employer National Insurance, pension, holiday and sick pay, payroll and insurance |
Sources: Homecare Association, "A Minimum Price for Homecare 2026/27, England" (homecareassociation.org.uk, published December 2025, covering April 2026 to March 2027) — £34.42 an hour; NHS, "Paying for your own care (self-funding)" (nhs.uk) around £20 an hour, and Age UK, "How much does care cost?" (ageuk.org.uk) around £25; National Living Wage £12.71 from April 2026 (GOV.UK). All checked October 2026.
So a private carer is usually cheaper per hour, and for a family on a tight budget that counts for a lot. But the agency's higher rate isn't all profit: it's buying the cover for sickness and holidays, the insurance, the checks and the admin. When you employ someone yourself, you either do that work or pay someone to do it, so the gap between the two rates is narrower than it first looks. The honest way to compare is to add the on-costs to the private carer's wage before you decide which is really cheaper.
What you take on if you employ a carer yourself
This is the part families most often underestimate. Taking a carer on directly, even for a few hours a week, usually makes you their employer, and an employer has legal duties. Carers UK and GOV.UK between them set out what's involved:
- Set up a way to pay wages and deduct income tax and National Insurance, and send those to HMRC. Care and support employers can't use the online registration tool — you register with HMRC by phone.
- Auto-enrol the carer into a workplace pension if they qualify, and pay into it.
- Give paid holiday under the Working Time Regulations, and handle statutory sick pay and any maternity or paternity pay they're due.
- Hold employers' liability insurance. By law it must cover you for at least £5 million, and you can be fined £2,500 for every day you don't have it. Public liability cover is sensible too.
- Check the carer's references, confirm they have the right to work in the UK, and see their DBS check (an Access NI check in Northern Ireland).
- Put a written contract in place and keep the home safe for someone to work in.
- Arrange and pay for a replacement yourself when your carer is off sick or on holiday.
None of this is a reason not to employ a carer. Thousands of families do it well, and many use a payroll service or a managed account to take the paperwork off their hands. But it is real work and real cost, and it's fairer to go in knowing about it than to discover the insurance rule after the carer has started.
Employed or self-employed, and why it matters
A lot of private carers describe themselves as self-employed, which sounds as though it saves you the employer duties above. Be careful here. It's your job, as the person taking the carer on, to decide whether they really count as employed or self-employed for tax — not the carer's, and not an introductory agency's.
HMRC looks at the facts of the arrangement, not the word on a contract. Broadly, if you decide when the carer works, where and how they do the job, and you provide what they need to do it, HMRC is likely to treat them as your employee whatever the paperwork says. Many carers found through introductory agencies don't actually meet the test for genuine self-employment, so a family that assumes "she's self-employed, it's not my problem" can be left owing back tax and National Insurance later. GOV.UK's free Check Employment Status for Tax tool gives you HMRC's view based on how the arrangement actually works, and it's worth running before you agree anything.
There's a related gap in England. An introductory agency that only matches you with a self-employed carer, and doesn't direct the care itself, may not be registered with the Care Quality Commission, because it isn't carrying out the regulated activity. So the inspection report you'd normally lean on for a managed agency won't exist, and more of the checking falls to you. Our guide to choosing a home care agency explains how to look a provider up with the regulator for your part of the UK.
Which one fits your situation
Neither route is better in the abstract; it depends on what the person needs and how much the family can take on.
An agency tends to be the easier choice when you don't want to become an employer, when reliable cover matters because there's no one to step in if a carer is off, or when the needs are complex or involve nursing tasks that call for close supervision. You also get the regulator's inspection report to lean on, which is reassurance in itself.
Employing a private carer often suits families where continuity is the thing that matters most — the same trusted face every day, especially for someone with dementia who finds new people unsettling — and where the needs are fairly steady and the family can manage the admin or pay a service to. It usually costs less once you've accounted for the on-costs, and it gives you the most control over who provides the care.
If the council or NHS is helping with the bill, a direct payment lets you arrange and pay for your own carer rather than taking the council's chosen agency, and the funding can often cover payroll support and the insurance you're required to hold. Our paying for care at home section explains assessments, direct payments and benefits, and the cost of home care page sets out the hourly and weekly rates in more detail.
Common questions
If you already know care is needed, tell us what's needed and where, and home care providers covering that postcode will contact you. It's free and there's no obligation.